West Tisbury Homes for Sale

Homes in West Tisbury provide residents with the opportunity to live in a rural atmosphere and enjoy a strong sense of community on Martha’s Vineyard. You’ll find cozy summer cottages, oceanfront properties, and estates with acres. Browse all homes for sale in West Tisbury below.

Houses for Sale in West Tisbury MA

Questions about buying a home in West Tisbury? Call Landmarks Real Estate: 508-693-6866

Save time & effort! Create an account to save your favorite listings & get notifications when similar properties become available.

100 Music Street

West Tisbury, MA100 Music Street

Price$2,100,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 37687

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 1644
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 2

This family-owned historic farmhouse offers the unique opportunity to own a home on West Tisbury's iconic, storied Music Street. Built in 1836, this lovingly maintained 5 bedroom house is filled with charm and character both inside and out. The interior is gracious and bright, with surprisingly high ceilings and large windows, wide-planked, original wood flooring, an elegant staircase with graceful, vintage banister, two fireplaces and a clawfoot tub. In the past, the house was used year-round heated by the fireplaces, but now serves the family as a beloved summer home and rental. The property was once a working farm with horses, sheep, fruit trees and poultry and offers an antique barn, sheep shed and frontage on Glimmerglass Pond on 3.6 generous pastoral acres with beautiful stonewalls and two curving driveways. West Tisbury means access to Lambert's Cove Beach. It's an easy bike or walk to the Ag Hall, or West Tisbury town center with the Farmer's market, Alley's and the town library. Please note: the house does not have a heating system beyond the wood burning fireplaces, and the two cesspools that serve the house function but do not pass Title V. The house is being sold "as is".

Listed by Tea Lane Associates

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

49 Old Courthouse Road

West Tisbury, MA49 Old Courthouse Road

Price$1,350,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 37399

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 3580
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 5

CHARMING & BUCOLIC IN WEST TISBURY - 2 majestic Oak trees guard the entrance to this pastoral setting of meadows, gardens and woods. Home to the Bayberry Inn for 30 years, this property is looking for a new owner with fresh vision for its next chapter. One may continue the Inn tradition, enjoy it as a single family residence or operate an assisted living facility here. Permits for a care facility are already in place and all requirements have been met. Old Courthouse Road is a quiet country lane with miles of trails that are ideal for walking and biking. With over 3,500 square feet this home has five bedrooms and ample living spaces. The unique Octagon sunroom addition has been a favorite place for family and friends to gather. This room is spacious and features a 15 foot high ceiling and a copper top roof that reverberates with musical sound during rain storms, making an ethereal sensation of peace and wonder. There is a formal living room with built in book shelves, a fireplace and a bay window that overlooks the large yard. Two working fireplaces add to the charm of this well loved home. Outside you will find a brick patio off of the dining room, a private backyard and a small orchard on the side yard with 7 different varieties of fruit trees. There is an attached garage that has been transformed to finished space, ideal for an additional bedroom. Miles of walking trails can be accessed at the end of Old Courthouse Road, as well as trails to Priester's Pond, just down the road. State Road Restaurant, Middletown Nursery and North Tisbury Farm & Market are just around the corner. Lambert's Cove Beach is also nearby and is an additional benefit to ownership in West Tisbury. Additional bedrooms are allowed and a new 7 bedroom septic system has been installed.

Listed by Wallace & Co. Sotheby's

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

556 Edgartown West Tisbury Road

MLS ID 37449

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 1428
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 1

If you are looking for a property with character, "The Suzie Scott House" has more than you can imagine. Built in circa 1850, the current owner purchased this well maintained home as part of a long time family owned Estate. This sweet Antique sits on 1.4 acres with several out buildings (including the original out house converted to a shed). This is a property to really make your own, while keeping the character of the era, and still putting your stamp on it. Enter through a screened porch which leads into the Main Living space. A large room at the front of the house, off the Living Room (now being used as a bedroom), with fireplace, could be easily converted into a Family room / Office. The cozy Kitchen with dishwasher, washing machine and extra large gas stove could be a beautiful restoration project. A dining, sitting room and 2 more bedrooms finish off the main level. A small staircase leads to 2 second Floor bedrooms and 1/2 bath complete this very special listing. When the current owner purchased this home, the community was thrilled to learn that he was keeping the house, with all its character, in tact. Notice newest work done, shingled sides and most of roof ...Any way you choose to go, this is a beautiful piece of property! There is something to be said for mixing some old with new to create a unique "Vineyard Home".

Listed by Martha's Vineyard Seacoast Properties

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

140 Sarita Walker Road

West Tisbury, MA140 Sarita Walker Road

Price$3,250,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 35219

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 1500
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 2

Traveling home each day you will pass the broad golden fields of hay shimmering in the sunlight. In-season, you'll be greeted by a vast sea of daisies waving in the breeze. You will observe horses grazing in the corrals and you will marvel at the majesty of ospreys hovering high above their towering nests keeping watch over the fields. You'll arrive at the water's edge on the sparkling shores of this scenic place. This is your home, located on Watcha Pond. This a premiere waterfront opportunity. Natural Heritage review is complete. Adjacent 3-acre vacant lot also for sale, bringing the opportunity to acquire over 6 acres of land. A rare find on the Island of Martha's Vineyard. $3,250,000

Listed by Rooney & Company

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

87 & 97 Longview Road

West Tisbury, MA87 & 97 Longview Road

Price$3,949,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 37143

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 4003
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 5

This beautifully designed Post and Beam home features amazing views of the Vineyard Sound, Elizabeth Islands and stunning sunsets. Bordered by stone walls and carefully sited on 2.2 acres, offering a private and peaceful setting, the main house includes 3 levels of living space. Upper level features a Great Room that includes living, dining and kitchen with cathedral ceilings, a stone fireplace and french doors that take you do a spacious deck. The master bedroom has many built-ins, a private deck and en-suite bath that includes a soaking tub and tiled shower. The second level offers a family room that opens to another spacious deck, a guest bedroom with full bath and a second master with private deck and en-suite bath. Lower level includes a game room with bunks, a full bath and laundry room. Super efficient Geothermal heating and cooling, wind turbine for electric savings. Almost zero fossil fuel with the exception of the Aga 6 burner stove. The detached 2-car garage offers a charming second floor 1 bedroom apartment. Separate 1.56 acre parcel included in the sale. BUYER'S BROKER MUST BE PRESENT AT ALL SHOWINGS AND APPOINTMENTS.

Listed by Karen M. Overtoom R.E.

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

100 Watcha Club Road

West Tisbury, MA100 Watcha Club Road

Price$7,500,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 36565

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 4380
  • Bedrooms 8
  • Bathrooms 5

WATERFRONT ESTATE ON THE SOUTH SHORE Secluded 12.6 acres beside pristine Watcha Pond and conservation land to the north. The 5 bedroom 3 bath 3,000+ sq ft main house has been lovingly maintained and offers stunning views of Watcha Pond and the Atlantic Ocean from all floors. These cleared views and sweeping lawn would not be possible were this an undeveloped building site, and the guest house may be used while a future owner designs a new home in the stunning setting. The 3 bedroom 2 bath 1100 sq ft guest house has sparkling water views of Watcha Pond and conservation land to the east and the Atlantic to the south. Designed by architect Joseph Dick and completed in 2015 the guest house has been lightly used and feels brand new. A large semi-attached “bunkhouse” with another half bath and outdoor shower makes a delightful summer home for children, or the bright room could be used as an artist studio or workspace. Shady moss-covered paths criss-cross the property's woods leading to the sandy Watcha Pond shore where you launch your kayak, canoe, or sailboat for the short trip across the pond to a deeded 500 foot stretch of Atlantic beach just 350 yards away. Idyllic summer days can be spent swimming and body surfing in the Atlantic, then diving into the sweet water of Watcha Pond. The area offers some of the Island's best birding and Watcha is a fisherman's paradise, full of Perch and ancient Pike. A subdivision plan has been drafted and sellers would consider selling the main house on 7.15 acres (addition of a guest house would be permitted). The property also has membership in a small Beach Association for walking and vehicle access to an Atlantic beach half a mile away via a quiet dirt road. A portion of this beach is expected to erode over the next decades, but the property's deeded beach access over Watcha Pond will remain in perpetuity.

Listed by Wallace & Co. Sotheby's

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

100 Pond Road

West Tisbury, MA100 Pond Road

Price$2,150,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 36533

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 4438
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 5

There is room for all in this sprawling 4,400+ SF contemporary cape style home in the upscale Deep Bottom Pond neighborhood. Set on a super private 4.5-acre lot with access to the Tisbury Great Pond for kayaking only a short walk from your backyard. The flow throughout the house is well planned and is bright and sunny, with soaring ceilings and loads of windows and glass doors letting the outside in. The spacious home offers five bedrooms and 5.5 baths including a grand master bedroom with en-suite, walk-in closet and french doors to the rear deck, numerous living areas, front farmers porch, back deck overlooking the beautifully landscaped grounds, 3- car garage and huge basement. Deep Bottom Pond an enclave of significant homes offering a pastoral setting with rolling fields and grazing horses, walking trails, tennis and water access to the Great Pond. Being sold turnkey.

Listed by Sandpiper Realty

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

52 Middle Road

West Tisbury, MA52 Middle Road

Price$8,750,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 35777

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 8700
  • Bedrooms 7
  • Bathrooms 7

The Kenney compound consists of the authentic updated 1719 Tilton House, wonderful estate cottage and stunning pool and a remarkable cathedral like barn and outdoor stone encircled paddock. The 1719 Tilton House is the perfect blend of authentic early American design and decor with 21st Century comfort and convenience. The Tilton House was lovingly restored and renovated in 2000 to its original splendor and doubled in size adding a modern kitchen, spacious sun room, two bedrooms, two full baths, a 4th fireplace and many other features. The 2006 superbly designed and decorated large cottage and exquisite pool area with incomparable Lew French stone sculptures compliments the 18th Century Tilton House. In addition, there is a large cathedral like barn often called the most stunning barn in the northeast. This combination of two homes, pool and barn on 25 private pastoral acres make this paradise one of the finest Vineyard estates. Words do not do justice to this property which has been a desirable venue for important charitable and cultural events over the last decade. QUANSOO BEACH LOT available separately !

Listed by Tea Lane Associates

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

37, 5 and 20 Stillpoint Meadows Road

MLS ID 34587

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 6726
  • Bedrooms 9
  • Bathrooms 7

"Stillpoint", this stunning compound is reintroduced with a fresh perspective and price. Stillpoint is the feeling when you enter this tranquil estate in West Tisbury on beautiful Martha's Vineyard. Classical New England elegance is combined with European influences that immediately transport one to Tuscany or the Cotswold's whilst encompassing quintessential American style. This 50 acre country estate is comprised of three dwellings; the elegant main Federal style home dates from 1795 and was brought to the Vineyard in 1987 from it's original site in the Berkshires. Complete with swimming pool and pool house, gorgeous landscaping and views over Priester Pond. Classical proportions provide 4 comfortable en suite bedrooms, ample living and entertaining rooms, and a fabulous gourmet kitchen with double doors to an amazing brick floor conservatory/sun room with bar area and another set of French doors to the pool terrace and gardens. The home is surrounded by beautiful landscaping including an Italian inspired terrace complete with fountain and meadow views. At the opposite end of the pool is a studio/ pool house currently used as an art studio. Across the driveway is a contemporary barn, built by South Mountain Company in 2012. The 2700 square foot barn is currently used as an event space, workshop and art space, but the building could easily convert to additional living space. A bank of solar roof panels provide power for this structure plus the main house. There's a outdoor fire pit and established vegetable garden. Across the lawn from the main home is an equally immaculate second home, which has been restored with the most impeccable attention to detail and taste. The Luce Athearn House, dates to 1714 and has 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. see full description under "2nd dwelling". The whole property has so many unique and interesting places to explore and just be at one with nature and the surrounding . 50 acres of meadow, woodland and frontage on two ponds.....and if that isn't enough, the property abuts Polly Hill arboretum and Land bank conservation land. A Stillpoint one feels like one could be anywhere in the world yet its just a 5 minute drive to West Tisbury center. A 10 minute drive to the airport or to the Vineyard Haven ferry. When it's time to finally leave one is left with a feeling of gratitude at being able to experience this jewel of a property. The peace and tranquility will draw you back.

Listed by Tea Lane Associates

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

44 Forest Road

West Tisbury, MA44 Forest Road

Price$12,800,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 34815

  • Residential
  • MlsStatus Active
  • Square Feet 4436
  • Bedrooms 6
  • Bathrooms 4

Quintessential Seven Gates waterfront compound. Outstanding Martha's Vineyard retreat. Stunning views and immediate sandy beachfront. The property features a main residence and barn designed and built by South Mountain Company. Immaculately kept, the structures are virtually turn-key. The interiors offer rich details, displaying highest level craftsmanship, and elegant design, perfect for seaside relaxation. Views of the Sound and Elizabeth Islands are readily available from nearly every room, including from the guest suite above the barn. Just off the main house is an inviting pool area, complete with bluestone patio, extensive stone walls and hardscape, and separate hot-tub area. The property is set within one of the most incomparable private areas of the Island. Seven Gates Farm has a rich history, and comprises approximately 1600 acres. In addition to generous private lot sizes, nearly 1000 common acres are held in permanent conservation with The Trustees of Reservations. Many gorgeous open fields, woodlands, ponds and private trails abound. Properties in the farm enjoy access to miles of private beach, two piers and two tennis courts. This is a coveted opportunity to reside within a timeless community, originally a collection of large farms, that has been deeply focused on preservation and stewardship since the late 1800's when the Head of Geology for Harvard University first developed his vision for Seven Gates Farm as a 'civil wilderness' that should be enjoyed, cherished and protected. Note: 2% fee to Seven Gates Farm in addition to purchase price and Land Bank. See below for additional details.

Listed by Compass

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 2.79% last updated on Jan 14, 2021
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details