West Tisbury Homes For Sale

West Tisbury is the largest of the Vineyard towns in terms of area, stretching from the North Shore hills of Makonikey to the flatlands of the island’s South Shore. Many of the homes for sale in West Tisbury offer residents a great deal of privacy, with a combination of rural and waterfront real estate available. The landscape is also dotted with art galleries, boutiques and renowned Polly Hill Arboretum and residents love West Tisbury’s Lambert's Cove and Long Point Beaches.

Learn more about West Tisbury.

At Coldwell Banker Landmarks we specialize in helping buyers find the perfect home for sale on Martha’s Vineyard. Our team has decades of experience in the local real estate market, so contact us to get started.

r=1-10
9 South Pond Road

Price$2,000,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 33335

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 3419
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 4
  • Acreage 1.46

Exceptional custom Rosbeck built home in Deep bottom Pond area of West Tisbury. The entrance opens into the great room which features vaulted ceilings and fireplace, a perfect area for family gatherings and entertaining. The open dining room and kitchen overlooks the gunnite pool and beautiful gardens. This property offers 5 bedrooms, with luxurious master suite that also opens to the pool area. The en suite bath has a double marble vanity, glass shower and spa. The first level also has a room with an attached bath that could serve as a fifth bedroom, office or family room. The second level has an additional en suite master and two bedrooms that share a bathroom. A partially finished basement and attached two car garage round out this great offering that if seen will be appreciated.

Listed by Ledden Properties LLC

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

25 Carls Way

Price$995,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 33224

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 1040
  • Bedrooms 3
  • Bathrooms 2
  • Acreage 3.1

Vineyard retreat offered for sale for the first time in many generations, 25 Carls Way is a level 3.1 acre property with a 3 bedroom/2 bathroom ranch style home with a full/finished basement, that's walking distance to your private deeded West Tisbury Great Pond access and Town Center. The private pond access allows boats of all sorts including a power boat for a short ride to the South Shore barrier beach. Rare enclave close to West Tisbury center, the Farmer's Market, Library, play ground, Alley's General Store and 7a restaurant, yet secluded from activity associated with a town center. An ideal location for peaceful Vineyard vacation with the opportunity for great privacy. Surrounded by three multi-million dollar homes designed by well known architects are some of your neighbors. Four bedroom septic. Expansion potential as long as setbacks met but please verify with town BOH and building inspectors.

Listed by RE/MAX on Island

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

54 Mayhew Norton Road

Price$1,295,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 33055

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 1747
  • Bedrooms 3
  • Bathrooms 2
  • Acreage 1.6

This lovely, unique home, nestled at the top of enchanting Indian Hill road, is warm with country charm and historic character. Recent extensive renovations include new windows, kitchen, bathroom and heating system, making this home comfortable for year round living. A covered porch welcomes you into the country kitchen complete with custom cabinets, soapstone counter tops and stainless steel appliances. The sun filled living room and wood paneled dining room each have fireplaces, beautiful wide pine floors and exposed timber ceilings. A cathedral post and beam addition houses the master bedroom suite with its own private bath, study and laundry. On the opposite end, is a second bright new bedroom and a charming renovated bathroom. The upper floor is its own separate sanctuary with a dormer ceiling bedroom and skylit sitting area. The heated walk out basement features exposed granite foundation walls and a beehive oven. A few steps from the house is the post and beam “Studio” which can also be used as an office and guest bedroom. The timber frame garage is spacious enough for a workshop and for storing bikes, surfboards and kayaks all conveniently accessible from the driveway. This 1.6 acre property is surrounded by pastoral beauty with mature trees, rolling hills and stone walls, all within a short distance of the trails of Cedar Tree Neck and hundreds of acres of conservation land.

Listed by Flanders Real Estate

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

221 & 223 John Cottle Road

MLS ID 33024

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 3864
  • Bedrooms 7
  • Bathrooms 5
  • Acreage 7.95

Paul's Point, one of the most treasured shorelines on Martha's Vineyard, known for its sandy shores, emerald waters and remarkable privacy, is home to this wondrous ocean front property. Perfectly manicured yet whimsical grounds sprawl over 8 acres with beetlebung groves, stonewalls and gently rolling meadow leading to nearly 200' of shoreline. The magic continues into the woodland over an artfully crafted footbridge through tall trees and over a rustling creek. Sitting high over the trees, the main residence offers captivating views and is an appealing design that includes 5 bedrooms on three levels and semi attached guest quarters. Stone steps weave through ample gardens to the vintage guest house and to the open expanse stretching to the water. A unique opportunity to own on this prestigious shoreline of legacy estates.

Listed by Sandpiper Realty

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

65 Trotters Lane

Price$2,150,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 32936

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 4090
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 4
  • Half Bath 1

Pastoral, private, and peaceful... An amazing locations not far from all the island has to offer. Located on a paved road on 9.5 acres of land, this spacious 4,000+ sf home features four bedrooms and four and a half baths with expansion possibilities. This post and beam style home has had light use since construction by current owners in 2006. Home has a large living room with vaulted ceiling and fireplace and yellow heart flooring. Great room is open to the gourmet kitchen and breakfast area. Many windows allow natural light to filter through the space. This level has two bedrooms, two and a half baths, and a spacious library. Enjoy out door living on the large deck or covered porch. The second floor has the two additional bedrooms and two full baths. The 7 bedroom septic would allow you to create a space on the ground level area that is currently unfinished. This space has approximately 3,000 sf of space with large windows. The three car garage is an added bonus. Enjoy all West Tisbury has to offer from this property.

Listed by Island Real Estate

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

655 Old County Road

Price$839,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 32800

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 2450
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Acreage 2.2

This story book cottage has many unique features. It is nestled into gently sloping grounds and surrounded by a landscaped lawn with many ornamental trees and flowers creating a beautiful outdoor space. This location offers close proximity to West Tisbury Village and all the conveniences the town offers. The home has a spacious main level consisting of a living area with barrel vault ceilings and a wood burning fireplace. Additionally there are three bedrooms, an updated large and sunny master bedroom (added in 1984) with cathedral ceilings, a fireplace, a cozy alcove for relaxed reading and a full ensuite bathroom. There is a second bedroom complete with barrel vault ceiling and a fireplace, and finally a third smaller bedroom well suited as a child's room or an office. A hallway bathroom completes this first floor. The entire upper level is encompassed by a wraparound deck accessed through both living areas and bedrooms. Downstairs the home opens up to an open concept living, dining, kitchen area with a large stone fireplace that opens to both the family room area and the dining area. The walls are exposed stone and concrete and lots of light comes in through the 2 sets of French doors leading to the patio and back yard. The fourth bedroom, laundry area and third bathroom are also on the lower level. The back yard is large and grassy and borders on the Mill Brook. Set back from the street with a circular driveway, this property provides privacy and great opportunities.

Listed by Tea Lane Associates

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

556 Edgartown West Tisbury Road

MLS ID 32768

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 1428
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 1
  • Half Bath 1

If you are looking for a property with character, "The Suzie Scott House" has more than you can imagine. Built in circa 1850, the current owner purchased this well maintained home as part of a long time family owned Estate. This sweet Antique sits on 1.4 acres with several out buildings (including the original out house converted to a shed). This is a property to really make your own, while keeping the character of the era, and still putting your stamp on it. Enter through a screened porch which leads into the Main Living space. A large room at the front of the house, off the Living Room (now being used as a bedroom) could be easily converted into a Family room / Office. The cozy Kitchen with dishwasher, washing machine and extra large gas stove could be a beautiful restoration project. A dining, sitting room and 2 more bedrooms finish off the main level. A small staircase leads to 2 second Floor bedrooms and 1/2 bath complete this very special listing. When the current owner purchased this home, the community was thrilled to learn that he was keeping the house, with all its character, in tact. Any way you choose to go, this is a beautiful piece of property ! There is something to be said for mixing some old with new to create a unique "Vineyard Home".

Listed by Martha's Vineyard Seacoast Properties

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

142 Otis Bassett Road

MLS ID 32110

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 1316
  • Bedrooms 3
  • Bathrooms 2
  • Acreage 0.89

Stylish Contemporary ranch. A perfect house as a rental investment property, a retirement home, or for a small family. It is easily maintained and is almost completely a new house. Some of the new features besides windows, elec., plumbing, roof and sunroom etc., include a dramatic 11' cathedral ceiling in living room w/ a corner gas fireplace w/black marble mantle, custom lighting. Eye-catching new kitchen with gray cabinets, quartz counters. Stone ceramic tile in both the kitchen and dining rooms, ceramic and subway tiles in the bathrooms, hardwood floors in all other rooms, glass door knobs. Master bedroom w/ en suite bath with ceramic glass counter top and sink. Two additional bedrooms share another stylish bath w/washer-dryer. Another feature includes a 10' x 14' enclosed porch/room that will be insulated and heated suitable for den or in home office with separate entrance. Completing the exterior setting one finds flower boxes, a wrap around mahogany deck in the front and side of the house, sod lawn with 2 zone irrigation. Ample parking in front and side of yard. Decorative fencing w/plantings throughout the exterior of the house. 10'x10' Nantucket shed, pre dipped tea green shingles. Attention to details is evident...simply charming! See other details on this property in Documents file. A garage and 800 sq.ft. accessory apartment is allowed on the lot or maybe you want a barn. Must be a yr. round resident for apt, requires special permit. and upgrade of septic. Title V certificate in place. Well tank and expansion tank replaced. JC Murphy has a financial interest in the property.

Listed by Hughes & JC Murphy R.E.

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

56 Willow Tree Hollow

MLS ID 31954

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 1600
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 2
  • Acreage 4.14

COMPLETELY RENOVATED IN WEST TISBURY. Willow Tree Hollow is a quiet road located in the heart of West Tisbury close to Alley's General Store, 7a foods and just a short drive to Longpoint Beach. Located on 4.14 acres, this home has undergone a complete high-end renovation both inside and out. The home features 4 bedrooms but there is lots of potential for future expansion with a new 6-bedroom septic. Renovations include, new bathrooms with Carrara marble floors and white subway tile, new windows, new exterior and interior doors, new solid hickory hardwood floors, new kitchen with white cabinets, granite countertops and stainless steel appliances, new paint, pergola over entry door, upgraded electrical, new hot water heater, and brand new mini-splits installed with AC. A great opportunity in West Tisbury not to be missed!

Listed by Wallace & Co. Sotheby's

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

666 Old County Road

Price$1,975,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 32263

  • Multi-Family
  • Village Downtown
  • Location 41.387298,-70.666532
  • Bedrooms 6
  • Bathrooms 3

House & Guest House! Beautifully designed and built 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home located in the heart of West Tisbury Village. Sited on 4.5 acres, this gracious home has beautiful wood floors, a gourmet kitchen that is any cooks joy, top of the line appliances, granite counter tops, an eat-in kitchen area and a fabulous family room with custom built-ins and stone fireplace. A more formal living and dining room with gas fire place for special occasions. The spacious master bedroom suite has it's own bath with jacuzzi tub and steam shower, 3 guest bedrooms and a shared bath. There is a 2-car garage and a finished family room in the basement with built-in bar and plenty of extra storage. The charming guest house is set privately apart from the main house with it's own garden, outside shower and parking. Lovely details include an open kitchen, dining and living room, 1 bedroom and full bath and an open loft used as a second bedroom. Both homes are heated with Gas FHA and central A/C. Excellent Rental History!

Listed by Karen M. Overtoom R.E.

{$office->Name}

Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate
15 Church Street
Vineyard Haven MA, 02568
Office: 508-693-6866

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.62% last updated on Jun 14, 2018
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details