West Tisbury Homes For Sale

West Tisbury is the largest of the Vineyard towns in terms of area, stretching from the North Shore hills of Makonikey to the flatlands of the island’s South Shore. Many of the homes for sale in West Tisbury offer residents a great deal of privacy, with a combination of rural and waterfront real estate available. The landscape is also dotted with art galleries, boutiques and renowned Polly Hill Arboretum and residents love West Tisbury’s Lambert's Cove and Long Point Beaches. Learn more about West Tisbury.  

Questions about buying a home in West Tisbury?

Call Coldwell Banker Landmarks Real Estate: 508-693-6866

Save time & effort! Create an account to save your favorite listings & get notifications when similar properties become available.

37, 5 and 20 Stillpoint Meadows Road

MLS ID 34587

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 6726
  • Bedrooms 9
  • Bathrooms 7
  • Half Bath 2

"Stillpoint", where time stands still. This is the feeling when you enter this tranquil historic estate in West Tisbury on beautiful Martha's Vineyard. Classical New England elegance is combined with European influences that immediately transport one to Tuscany or the Cotswold's whilst encompassing quintessential American style. This 50 acre country estate is comprised of three dwellings; the elegant main Federal style home dates from 1795 and was brought to the Vineyard in 1987 from it's original site in the Berkshires. Complete with swimming pool and pool house, gorgeous landscaping and views over Priester Pond. Classical proportions provide 4 comfortable en suite bedrooms, ample living and entertaining rooms, and a fabulous gourmet kitchen with double doors to an amazing brick floor conservatory/sun room with bar area and another set of French doors to the pool terrace and gardens. The home is surrounded by beautiful landscaping including an Italian inspired terrace complete with fountain and meadow views. At the opposite end of the pool is a studio/ pool house currently used as an art studio. Across the driveway is a contemporary barn, built by South Mountain Company in 2012. The 2700 square foot barn is currently used as an event space, workshop and art space, but the building could easily convert to additional living space. A bank of solar roof panels provide power for this structure plus the main house. There's a outdoor fire pit and established vegetable garden. Across the lawn from the main home is an equally immaculate second home, which has been restored with the most impeccable attention to detail and taste. The Luce Athearn House, dates to 1714 and has 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. see full description under "2nd dwelling". The whole property has so many unique and interesting places to explore and just be at one with nature and the surrounding . 50 acres of meadow, woodland and frontage on two ponds.....and if that isn't enough, the property abuts Polly Hill arboretum and Land bank conservation land. A Stillpoint one feels like one could be anywhere in the world yet its just a 5 minute drive to West Tisbury center. A 10 minute drive to the airport or to the Vineyard Haven ferry. When it's time to finally leave one is left with a feeling of gratitude at being able to experience this jewel of a property. The peace and tranquility will draw you back.

Listed by Tea Lane Associates

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

30 Luce Farm Road

Price$2,950,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 34873

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 5626
  • Bedrooms 6
  • Bathrooms 4
  • Acreage 9.69

A substantial family home built by Holmes Hole Builders in 2003 on almost 10 acres off Indian Hill Road . High ceilings throughout the home with gracious open living areas and beautiful wide plank hardwood floors. Very tasteful and charming. The main floor is designed to allow space to connect with guests/family while looking over the land. The kitchen is a fabulous space to gather with its adjoining screened in porch complete with a beautiful outside fireplace. This large modern space includes a great dining area with French doors to a sunny bluestone patio as well as a sitting area around the stone fireplace. The main front entrance opens to the formal dining and living rooms where there's a wrap-around porch which gives the home a great sense of bringing the outdoor in and also serves as a wonderful winter space for cozy family holidays and entertaining. There are a total of 6 bedrooms and 3 baths on the second floor with a huge master suite including office with fireplace, and walk though closet, full bath with tub and glass enclosed shower. The five further bedrooms have shared Jack-and-Jill baths with glass enclosed showers and a tub in one of the baths. The design includes 2 conveniently placed laundry rooms on both levels, and a 4th full bath on the first floor. The house is located on beautiful land, close to lovely Sheriffs Meadow trail system and North shore beach walks at Cedar Tree Neck. Close to town amenities making this a great year round location or summer retreat. The home has never been used as a rental but could be a great rental property or investment. Such a large beautiful piece of land with interesting topography and substantial trees.

Listed by Tea Lane Associates

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

9 Nats Farm Lane

Price$749,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 35039

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 1571
  • Bedrooms 3
  • Bathrooms 2
  • Acreage 1.47

Three Bedroom two bathroom Custom built Home located in West Tisbury on Nats farm lane. this home sits on 1.47 acres of mostly wooded land and has a lot of POTENTIAL!!! Exterior needs Maintenance and interior needs some updating. updated mini split w/Ac/heat located on the first floor and a new on-demand hot water in the basement. a rare opportunity to buy in this sought after location that is 2 minute walk to the West Tisbury school and neighbors land bank property.

Listed by Ocean Park Realty Inc

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

666 Old County Road

Price$1,950,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 35087

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 3611
  • Bedrooms 6
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Half Bath 1

House & Guest House! Beautifully designed and built 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home located in the heart of West Tisbury Village. Sited on 4.5 acres, this gracious home has beautiful wood floors, a gourmet kitchen that is any cooks joy, brand new top of the line appliances, granite counter tops, an eat-in kitchen area and a fabulous family room with custom built-ins and stone fireplace. A more formal living and dining room with gas fire place for special occasions. The spacious master bedroom suite has it's own bath with jacuzzi tub and steam shower, 3 guest bedrooms and a shared bath. There is a 2-car garage and a finished family room in the basement with built-in bar and plenty of extra storage. The charming guest house is set privately apart from the main house with it's own garden, outside shower and parking. Lovely details include an open kitchen, dining and living room, 1 bedroom and full bath and an open loft used as a second bedroom. Both homes are heated with Gas FHA and central A/C. Excellent Rental History!

Listed by Karen M. Overtoom R.E.

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

5 Murphys Road

Price$1,625,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 35070

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 3180
  • Bedrooms 6
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Half Bath 1

This Magical West Tisbury two story, 3,280 square foot home with full basement, is a great value in today's market. An attached studio is separate from the first floor living space. The gorgeous pond views out the back add to your daily enjoyment. Just walk across the road to Mermaid Farm farm stand or take a hike on the hundreds of acres of trails outside your door. Your family will find much to love for generations to come.

Listed by Feiner Real Estate

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

5 Murphys Road

Price$1,625,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 35063

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 3180
  • Bedrooms 6
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Half Bath 1

Forever Farm Views. With permanent conservation restrictions in place this six bedroom expanded farmhouse over looks a pastoral environment surrounded by fields dotted with grazing livestock, serene pond and ancient stone walls.With over 3000 square feet of living space, not only does every window look out onto picturesque farm views,but the property comes with 3 outbuildings for creative consideration. Over sized rooms, 2 Fireplaces, and ample living space on the first level to create a multi generational living option.

Listed by Conroy & Company R.E., Inc.

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

53 Nip and Tuck Lane

MLS ID 34996

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 3732
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Half Bath 2

At the end of a beautiful private driveway lies this family compound! Pulling in to a large circular driveway you are at a guesthouse garage and a continuous ranch with a 2.5 car garage. There is a large private backyard surrounded by conservation . Within a 5 minute drive to Vineyard Haven, this house is completely private. Both properties were built by the owner who was a prominent builder on the Vineyard for years! Ground floor living, you enter into a real country kitchen with fireplace, a sun bathed living room, a formal dining area with a large master bedroom suite and two more bedrooms with a shared bath. There is great separation in the living space which allows the owners great privacy. There is an unfinished second floor which is a kid's playroom complete with regulation pool table!

Listed by Jane Brown Assoc.

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

5 Pine Lane

Price$929,900

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 34867

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 2419
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Acreage 1.877

Unique Main House-Guest House Compound on 1.9 lovely wooded acres provides both privacy and a wonderful nature experience with mature landscaping. Built in 1980 and remodeled in 1989, the Main house provides a single-story, 2000 square foot open floor plan with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sunroom, skylight, library, living room, office area, and 1700 sq ft of climate-controlled basement for either living space or storage. New gas fired boiler provides effective hot water baseboard heat for efficient year-round living, along with top-grade low- E Anderson Casement windows. Sizable 500 square foot deck for maximum outdoor fun with guests. One of a kind guest house offers a two-story structure with upstairs studio loft with wainscoting, kitchen, skylight, and dining area overlooking woods. Downstairs bath and bedroom with garage. Ideal location with quick access to both Up Island and Down Island locales. Fabulous family compound waiting for the right buyer!

Listed by Karen M. Overtoom R.E.

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

44 Forest Road

Price$14,000,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 34815

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 4436
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 4
  • Acreage 4.2

Quintessential Seven Gates waterfront compound. Outstanding Martha's Vineyard retreat. Stunning views and immediate sandy beachfront. The property features a main residence and barn designed and built by South Mountain Company. Immaculately kept, the structures are virtually turn-key. The interiors offer rich details, displaying highest level craftsmanship, and elegant design, perfect for seaside relaxation. Views of the Sound and Elizabeth Islands are readily available from nearly every room, including from the guest suite above the barn. Just off the main house is an inviting pool area, complete with bluestone patio, extensive stone walls and hardscape, and separate hot-tub area. The property is set within one of the most incomparable private areas of the Island. Seven Gates Farm has a rich history, and comprises approximately 1600 acres. In addition to generous private lot sizes, nearly 1000 common acres are held in permanent conservation with The Trustees of Reservations. Many gorgeous open fields, woodlands, ponds and private trails abound. Properties in the farm enjoy access to miles of private beach, two piers and two tennis courts. This is a coveted opportunity to reside within a timeless community, originally a collection of large farms, that has been deeply focused on preservation and stewardship since the late 1800's when the Head of Geology for Harvard University first developed his vision for Seven Gates Farm as a 'civil wilderness' that should be enjoyed, cherished and protected. Note: 2% fee to Seven Gates Farm in addition to purchase price and Land Bank. See below for additional details.

Listed by Compass

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details

4 Windy Way

Price$4,650,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS ID 31464

  • Residential
  • Square Feet 2640
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Acreage 3.3

One of the most dramatic and sweeping water views on the Vineyard - at over 100' above sea level, the unobstructed views are stunning and stretch from Aquinnah to Woods Hole. The 3.3 acre private setting is most picturesque with grassy lawn and rolling dunes and only a short stroll away is 3,000+ feet of sandy association beach. Nestled into the countryside is a comfortable and sunny four bedroom contemporary style home that was designed to achieve water views from many rooms. Also included is a detached artist's studio that may be transformed into a future guest house. Expansion options are plenty with a 6 bedroom septic in place. Located in Upper Makonikey, an exclusive rural enclave that boasts the up-island lifestyle yet is an easy drive to town. Enjoy long days on the beach and savor the endless sunsets at this special place, where the rest of the world feels far away.

Listed by Sandpiper Realty

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 4.2% last updated on Apr 25, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Save FavoriteSchedule A VisitAsk A QuestionMore Details